Showing posts with label books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books. Show all posts

Saturday, September 3, 2011

severus snape, meet immanuel kant

Today, I saw the last Harry Potter movie again. Three or four years ago, I took a course on "Kant's Moral Theory in Film and Literature." This is the kind of thing that results.

Snape is one of my favorite characters in the Harry Potter books. Of course at the beginning he was just that professor you love to hate for his irrational prejudice against your heroes, but by the end of book six, when he had seemingly revealed his true colors and betrayed Dumbledore, I knew that the story wasn't over. Little hints, clues suggested that Snape was more than he appeared, a hunch that was confirmed in the seventh book. Snape, as it turns out, was perhaps *the* ultimate example of sacrificial love from the books. Many people die for Harry's sake (including Harry himself), but Snape's sacrifice is perhaps the greatest as it is unknown, unrewarded and uncertain of result.

Snape's actions somehow connected to my memories of college classes in Kant's moral theory. If I remember correctly, one of Kant's ideas about moral behavior was that TRUE moral action was done solely for it's own sake. In other words, if you were doing the right thing because a) it made you feel good or b) you'd feel guilty if you didn't or c) you benefited in any way--that action was not *quite* as moral or good as the action of someone who was acting simply out of duty. (This may be a gross oversimplification or misstatement, but this is what I remember.)

Snape, then, is almost the perfect Kantian moral agent. He receives no benefit from his service to Dumbledore, his protection to Harry--he refuses to be recognized, he doesn't like Harry, and at the very end he is told that all his work has been for nothing, as it were. And yet he continues until the very end, obeying Dumbledore's orders even when he has nothing to gain by it, because he has promised to do so, based on his love for Lily Potter.

I wonder what Immanuel Kant would say to that?

Monday, August 8, 2011

at a loss for words

I just finished reading Anna Karenina last night, a project that has taken about a month and a half. It has been one of the best reading projects I've ever undertaken--even when there was excessive detail about Russian agricultural methods, I was still soaking in the world of the story and as I moseyed my way along, there were so many great things to think about, or moments to enjoy. I'm not sure I've ever read a novel that was so satisfying on so many levels--philosophically, culturally, spiritually, emotionally, linguistically.

If I had to describe the story in one word, it would be: coherent. Tolstoy takes a vast array of material--historical events, cultural images, philosophical and political thought, Russian geography, religion, and his cast of characters--and weaves them all together into one story, in an attempt to convey truth as he sees it. Everything in the story conspires to support the grand conclusion reached by Levin in the last chapters of the book, "Now I say that I know the meaning of my life: 'To live for God, for my soul.'" I'd argue that the real heart of Anna Karenina is not Anna herself, but rather Levin and his intellectual journey from idealism and doubt, to realism and faith.

That said, there is so much to the story that shouldn't be crammed into a thematic box. Anna Karenina is first, and foremost, a novel. Tolstoy's characters are all carefully drawn and very real--sometimes in delightful, sometimes in painful ways. I found myself sympathizing with all the characters, even when I disliked them.
There are moments of humor, sarcasm (Tolstoy's sense of irony manages to come through, even in translation), tragedy, joy, love--the whole range of human emotions. And Tolstoy is very fond of using overt symbolism--the fact that Vronsky and Anna have a significant second encounter in the middle of a violent snowstorm? Not subtle, Uncle Tolstoy, not subtle.

In short, I highly recommend Anna Karenina to EVERYONE. I understand that not everyone may have the patience to slog through all the commentary on Russian culture (even I had trouble with the extended sequence about bird-hunting), but there is so much richness to be mined from the story, it's totally worth the time investment. And if you can't be bothered to read the whole thing, at least read the (very short!) Part 8, which details Levin's conversion to faith and is a beautiful affirmation of life, goodness and belief in God.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

victorian novels and vancouver spring

So the theme of the week (being performed with varying amounts of gusto) is waiting.

- Variation one: Vancouver spring
Everyone, without exception, has been saying this is the coldest, wettest, latest, most miserable spring in ages. And we keep saying it, over and over, because summer keeps not arriving. The momentous occasion of a few weeks ago is sadly becoming a distant memory.
But we wait. Summer IS coming (and is apparently going to be a scorcher when it comes). Wait, wait wait.

- Variation two: Victorian novels
I just finished reading North and South, by Elizabeth Gaskell, for Mapping Gender, one of the courses I'm auditing this spring. I wonder sometimes if the reading energy of my youth has been permanently damaged by my now five years of post-secondary education--I now find it more difficult to really sink my teeth into a novel and become completely absorbed. Especially when said novel is Victorian, and thus contains a) at least a few descriptions that cause me to roll my eyes and b) a plot that moves at the speed of molasses.
Of course, that's what I would have said three days ago, when I was stuck around the halfway point of North and South. I was starting to see major themes developed and kicked around, the tension between the two main characters was building, and I just couldn't seem to plow forward. It took a moment of stepping back, realizing that I was perhaps more engaged with the characters than I would like to admit--and then charging forward with the leap of faith that if I read the book straight through to the end, it would somehow be good.
The amazing thing--it was. I had forgotten that the slow development of plot at the beginning of the book means that once you move past halfway, things began to happen with a kind of tragic inevitability--you KNOW what's going to happen (mostly) and yet you can't stop reading because you can't wait to see it happen before your very eyes. There's something very satisfying as the whole tale sweeps together loose ends in a way that is both painful (people die, hearts are broken) and joyful (redemption occurs! relationships are made!).
So note to self: Victorian novels require waiting. Sometimes even waiting past the midway point. But you read through the beginning, even savor it, waiting for the great conclusion that you know is coming. Perhaps this philosophy will finally get me past the first 300 pages of Middlemarch until the end.

Monday, May 10, 2010

Really good books I have read this year, novels and non-fiction edition.

So I was trying to read more books this year. It has kind of been happening. I've noticed that while I still read fantasy, young-adult and children's literature when I want a quick book fix, some of the most satisfying things I've read this year are what I consider "grown-up" novels and non-fiction.

- Outliers, Malcolm Gladwell
I wouldn't call Outliers brilliant non-fiction writing but Malcolm Gladwell is a journalist by trade, so it's interesting and easy to read. Outliers is about success and how it happens. Gladwell's main thesis challenges the idea of a meritocracy, instead claiming that success is a combination of being in the right place in the right time and working hard. It's a thought-provoking read, and seemed especially apt during this LVC year because we're all about dissecting privilege and discovering the root causes of things like poverty and success.
I've also read Blink, by the same author and it has confirmed my suspicion that his books are all similar in tone and content. I'd say you'd only need to read one to really enjoy. Because Outliers is about success, I found it more interesting than Blink. However, if you're more into decision-making and psychology, Blink might be the better recommendation.

- Mountains Beyond Mountains: The Quest of Dr. Paul Farmer, a Man Who Would Cure the World, Tracy Kidder
Everyone should read this book, for a variety of reasons. For me, I learned more about Haiti, public health and grassroots change through this book than any college class could teach in the same amount of time and pages. In addition, simply reading about the issues, I started to care about world health and the situation in Haiti (this was before the earthquake), which was a personal change for me. But most importantly, Mountains Beyond Mountains showed me both the variety and complexity of problems facing the world (tuberculosis in Haiti and Chile, who knew?) but also the change that can occur when one person bends their will to a very specific task. An enlightening and empowering read.

- Shadow of the Wind, by Carlos Ruiz Zafon
I could not tell you plot details of this novel or exactly why I remember it as being so good. But it was. It's a slightly dark, cob-webby kind of novel, taking its cue from its namesake--a book named "Shadow of the Wind" within the story. (At work today I learned that there's a word for titles-related-to-contents-of-book--eponymous. But I still don't know enough about the word to use it casually in writing. /tangent) The story is a heady rush through the back streets of Spain, hidden libraries and ghostly mansions; my highest praise is that it evokes my memories of Spain, only with a fantastic magical lens, and it is glorious.

- The God of Small Things, Arundhati Roy
I'm tempted to compare this to Shadow of the Wind because a) it is not an American novel in style, setting or author, b) I read it really quickly and c) it has the same atmospheric, evocative quality of Shadow of the Wind, firmly established in a place as part of the story.
However, I read The God of Small Things more recently, so I can also say that Arundhati Roy is a master storyteller, cleverly revealing the plot in bits and pieces as she simultaneously paints a portrait of a family and a place. The language and imagery is fantastic, perfectly suited to the Indian setting.

- Crime and Punishment, Fyodor Dostoevsky
It took me at least two months to finish this book, mostly because Dostoevksy is all-too-brilliant at putting the reader inside the mind of an insane man and I couldn't read more than a couple of chapters without needing to rest my head. I also needed to remind myself that one does not read Dostoevsky novels for plot--they're all about character and ideas. Once I'd spent a couple of weeks slogging through those two parts of the Russian-novel-reading training regime, I breezed through the end in a week or so.
Dostoevsky, how do I love/hate thee? Let me count the ways. I'm pretty sure I would never read him if he wasn't considered a "classic" author. I also probably wouldn't get as much out of his novels if I wasn't deliberately looking for depth. But because it *is* Dostoevsky and I *am* looking for profundity, I thought Crime and Punishment was brilliant. His characters are incredibly real. You may have to wade through a swamp of words to get there, but Raskolnikov is REAL, from head to toe, crazy actions and crazy thoughts. Dostoevsky also deals with some heavy stuff in Crime and Punishment--you know, murder, alcoholism, prostitution, rape, the usual--and because the characters are so real, I was completely in sympathy with them. Then there's the actual political and religious ideas that Dostoevsky plugs into the mouths of his characters--questions of utility, order, and forgiveness. I'll need to read Crime and Punishment again to get a handle on what he was trying to say there.